Huey, Dewey, and Louie wake up one Christmas morning and run downstairs, excited to open their presents before Daisy, Scrooge, and Gertie arrive. The boys then take their new sleds from Donald without reading the attached card and go sledding. After dinner, as Donald, Daisy, Scrooge, and Gertie sing carols, the boys play with their new toys. Having enjoyed the day immensely, the trio doesn't want it to end, so they wish upon a star to have Christmas every day.
They find the next morning that their wish has been granted, and at first, they are joyful. After a few days, however, they realize that every Christmas will be exactly the same, tiring them out greatly. The following day, the trio decides to "liven things up" with a series of tricks and pranks, including swapping the cooked turkey with a live one at dinner. The turkey runs amok through the house, and chaos ensues as Donald gives chase. The boys, distraught at what they have done, read Donald and Daisy's card that came with the sleds and realize Christmas isn't about presents or decorations; it is about love, caring, and being with family. The boys vow to make the next day the best Christmas possible to make up for their actions.