The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "So long as this film makes no effort to create a dramatic scene or to talk seriously to the audience it is gaily and romantically successful; the comedy is unforced and the high spirits infectious. But when John Cassavetes, always too intense, begins to sermonise on independence, Virginia Maskell to preach about the tribulations of writers, and Isabel Dean to speak an uncomfortable monologue about being cut off from life, the film discloses an unnerving capacity to raise a squirm among the more worldly audiences. Sidney Poitier's outrageous caricature of the laughing West Indian hovers constantly on the verge of the sinister, but his ebullience, and the crisp, clean-living appeal of Miss Maskell in her less serious moods, are the film's two undeniable assets."
Picture Show wrote: "John Cassavetes and make a good team in this delightful romantic comedy. The story of how they meet, marry and set up home on an uninhabited island is lightweight but charms nevertheless. The island settings are beautiful and are photographed excellently. A most appealing and enjoyable film."